During the town hall, participants argued for both elimination and maintenance with adjustments.
On Friday, November 20, 2026, the American Medical Association (AMA) CPT Editorial Panel (Panel) hosted a town hall to review the most debated requirement for a Category I CPT code: widespread use. To qualify as a new or revised Category I CPT code, several requirements must be met. Category I CPT codes describe well-established services and procedures. These requirements help the Panel determine whether a proposal for a new or revised Category I CPT code is appropriate.
Over the years, the Panel has received questions and feedback about the widespread use requirement and, during the town hall, said it is eager to address these concerns promptly. This discussion, held as a virtual town hall with an opportunity for participants to provide feedback, was framed as part of ongoing efforts to modernize the Panel process.
What is the widespread use requirement?
Widespread use refers to two requirements for Category I CPT codes:
The procedure or service is performed by many physicians or other qualified healthcare professionals across the United States.
The procedure or service is performed with frequency consistent with the intended clinical use (i.e., a service for a common condition should have high volume).
Both requirements were discussed at the town hall. A complete list of requirements for Category I CPT codes is available HERE.
What feedback has the Panel received on the widespread use requirement?
Over the years, the Panel has received public feedback about the difficulties it encounters with this requirement.
Unclear expectations: No definition or a lack of clarity on how the requirement is applied.
Limited data: There are gaps in claims data, and it is unclear how the Panel evaluates the data it receives.
Catch-22: Demonstrating widespread use usually depends on the coverage and payment that a Category I code provides.
What feedback was received during the November 20, 2026 town hall?
Town hall participants who provided comments were primarily reimbursement and marketing consultants, trade association representatives for medical device manufacturers, and representatives from the diagnostic community. A couple of current CPT and RVS Update Committee (RUC) advisors and consultants who work with medical specialty societies also commented.
While there was general agreement that the widespread use requirement was problematic, public commenters held a range of opinions on how to address it. Commenters generally split into two camps: those who wanted to eliminate the widespread use criteria entirely and those who felt it was problematic yet necessary, believing that adjustments to the requirement could address concerns. Generally, those in the latter category felt that coding and valuation could not be separated and that a certain level of utilization was needed to ensure sufficient data could be collected during the RUC survey process.
Key Themes from the Town Hall Public Comments
Eliminate: Remove the criteria entirely; it is not relevant. Some suggested that in certain circumstances where its use had been established (e.g., diagnostics, USPTF recommendation), it was not needed.
Need for greater clarity and transparency: Multiple commenters suggested that there was a need for greater clarity about the types of utilization the Panel will accept. One commenter who worked with small startups noted that planning for coding and reimbursement was time-consuming and expensive for her clients. She urged the Panel to make the process more transparent and predictable.
Expand data sources: Numerous commenters suggested expanding beyond claims data. Suggestions included national, validated registries (e.g., transplant registries), sales data, and utilization data from cases in which a clinician was asked to perform the service but the hospital would not allow it because the hospital would not be paid for the service. It was suggested that the Panel could rely on other data sources as proxies when claims data was unavailable.
Expand Panel feedback on rejected applications: Some commenters suggested that when a code application is rejected under this requirement, the Panel should provide more detail to the submitter (e.g., whether it just missed the threshold or substantially more utilization was needed). There was acknowledgment that expected utilization varies by procedure/service. One commenter noted that, based on experience with numerous CPT applications, the process had been “non-uniform.” This commenter suggested that it would be helpful to hold discussions with Panel reviewers before the meeting to allow the code application submitter to explain their data and unique circumstances.
Build a case record: Similar to the comments about greater feedback from the Panel, one commenter suggested that the Panel could build a case record of CPT applications across various procedures and services to help potential code application submitters better understand the type of data the Panel accepts and how it is evaluated.
Widespread use requirement is needed: While there was strong support for eliminating the widespread use criteria, some commentators felt the criteria were necessary, especially to ensure an adequate survey pool for the RUC survey process, which is part of the valuation process for new and revised Category I CPT codes. One commenter suggested that if there is insufficient utilization to survey the code, the code would not be surveyed and could be carrier-priced. Another commenter suggested that the AMA needed to do more to educate the physician community about the importance of the RUC survey process.
Is it too late to provide feedback to the Panel?
It is not too late to provide feedback. The Panel has opened a written comment period. Comments should be directly related to experiences and/or impacts related to the widespread use criteria in the CPT Panel process.
Submit written comments by 4 p.m. Central on Sunday, Dec. 13, 2026. More information is available HERE.
What will the Panel do next?
Panel staff indicated that they will summarize all comments received via the town hall and in writing and share them with the public. The plan is to provide information on next steps soon – “not to sit on it for months.”
__________________
For more information and questions, please contact:
Sheila Madhani
Madhani Healthcare Consulting
Email: smadhani@madhani-health.com
Tel: (202) 679-2977